Page: « 1 2

10-08-2010 22:11:19

IrisAnne

Topics: 3

Replies: 16

Joined: Jul 2010

I still do prefer the anime to the drama, but they were both good in different aspects. So they're a really fun and funny watch. You'll enjoy! Plus the music is definitely a great addition.
28-11-2010 14:49:21

blackitty

Topics: 15

Replies: 210

Joined: Jun 2009

I will give it a try after I finish to watch beethoven virus.

the anime was great so i think that the drama cant fall short
15-02-2011 10:55:04

timizero

Topics: 2

Replies: 7

Joined: Feb 2011

i still go for anime in terms of stories...it is more detail compared to drama and some characters in anime are not in drama...
but as we all know, anime came later after the drama..so it is no surprise that they can produced a better story

however in terms of characterization i would go for drama....
So..., credit to actors and directors of the drama because their realized the characters very well...
30-04-2011 08:21:29

blackitty

Topics: 15

Replies: 210

Joined: Jun 2009

Just finished watching it. and to be honest I think I was looking foward to it too much and the real thing didn't live up to my expectations
30-04-2011 09:28:49

mahvish

Topics: 2

Replies: 46

Joined: Apr 2011

well now, this was a FANTASTIC drama! it had pure manga-ish humor, friendship, determination, love and .... a pervert of a Teacher,"Milch" Sensei smiley of boss hahaha boy did i enjoy this series or what! even the specials were great!

what i loved about it was how they turned a manga to an anime to a drama KEEPING the core alike! i mean usually when u see a manga based drama, it normally loses its manga-ish feel of abrupt humor, but this one had it! smiley of erm

i'd recommend it to anyone who's interested in music and a fun time for a drama smiley of haha
Just finished watching it. and to be honest I think I was looking foward to it too much and the real thing didn't live up to my expectations

aw really? how come? where were you disapointed the most?
01-05-2011 10:56:12

blackitty

Topics: 15

Replies: 210

Joined: Jun 2009

aw really? how come? where were you disapointed the most?
not really sure, in the anime it was funny, but the drama was annoying it seemed that instead of being funny they were making a fool of themselves, also I didn't think that the actor who acted as chiaki was the right choise. the story I also felt it was better in the anime, but this is only my opinion.
02-05-2011 11:00:16

mahvish

Topics: 2

Replies: 46

Joined: Apr 2011


not really sure, in the anime it was funny, but the drama was annoying it seemed that instead of being funny they were making a fool of themselves, also I didn't think that the actor who acted as chiaki was the right choise. the story I also felt it was better in the anime, but this is only my opinion.

well if you put it that way i'd agree with you, though i havent seen the anime, but felt just the same way when they turned Yamato Nadeshiko Shichi Henge into a drama, total kill-joy that turned out to be smiley of cold
02-05-2011 19:39:30

blackitty

Topics: 15

Replies: 210

Joined: Jun 2009



well if you put it that way i'd agree with you, though i havent seen the anime, but felt just the same way when they turned Yamato Nadeshiko Shichi Henge into a drama, total kill-joy that turned out to be smiley of cold

I also felt the same about Yamato Nadeshiko drama, first of all it didn't follow the original story at all and its true that more that funny it was foolish.
Well I thinks that the double edge of turning a comedy anime into a drama, you dont know if you could end up with a masterpiece or just with a pathetic attemp of that.
10-05-2011 06:36:49

mahvish

Topics: 2

Replies: 46

Joined: Apr 2011



I also felt the same about Yamato Nadeshiko drama, first of all it didn't follow the original story at all and its true that more that funny it was foolish.
Well I thinks that the double edge of turning a comedy anime into a drama, you dont know if you could end up with a masterpiece or just with a pathetic attemp of that.

exactlly! its happened with so many mangas turned dramas that i feel sad for the author and angry at the director! and recently there's been this trend going on to "lets-ruin-the-original-story" with so many dramas based on the books. even hollywood movies!
23-06-2011 17:46:03

Arzack

Arzack

Topics: 21

Replies: 297

Joined: Mar 2011

Is it worth to watch and download it?
31-03-2012 21:15:15

tendele

Topics: 45

Replies: 245

Joined: Jan 2009

definitely yes, i love this show so much
02-04-2012 09:45:27

mori

Topics: 0

Replies: 1

Joined: Apr 2012

it is the best you should watch it, there is two seasons and a special and movie.smiley of hooraysmiley of I am number 1

In my opinion, the drama is better than the anime.smiley of ahahasmiley of cool
01-05-2012 14:12:19

Ash Starrk

Topics: 2

Replies: 48

Joined: Jan 2012

I really love this series very much!
Click to view image at true resolution
14-09-2012 17:38:19

anime_earth

Topics: 1

Replies: 9

Joined: Sep 2012

i kinda liked live action drama... it's really amazing how they actually emulate the manga and everything...

hope they'll make the opera hen series live action drama as well...

overall this is a good music manga... another one I would've recommend is piano no mori ( which is also about music manga )
13-11-2012 03:32:24

pasentodos

Topics: 18

Replies: 14

Joined: Apr 2009

it's the first drama i ever watched, and still totally a favourite - i might be due for a re-watch soon....
14-11-2012 16:44:32

eby

Topics: 7

Replies: 96

Joined: Nov 2012

I love it!! I think the drama is better because it seems more like reality. hehe
06-06-2013 08:13:48

Natsume27

Topics: 0

Replies: 29

Joined: Aug 2012

This is better than the manga. Chiaki is much better here. Its the perfect Chiaki!
KDRAMA
JDRAMA
ANIME
MANGA

Page: « 1 2

Chatbox